Perennial Grains Could Be the Future of Sustainable Agriculture | Article

Agricultural grains, which make up more than 70 percent of global croplands, are almost always annual crops. They must be replanted every year and require farmers to use soil-intensive practices such as tilling, plowing, and applying herbicides.
The well-developed root systems of perennial grain crops (which live for more than two years) extend deep into the ground and help the soil absorb water and carbon dioxide. They also protect the soil from erosion with continuous coverage.
KernzaⓇ perennial grain is the first commercially available and economically viable perennial grain crop and is a suitable ingredient for bread, cereals, beer, whiskey, and even ice cream.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Conservation Stewardship Program was recently updated to include perennials, which will help direct conservation funding towards the adoption of perennial grain crops like Kernza.

When left undisturbed, naturally-occurring vegetation tends to grow back year after year. In agriculture, this is also true of perennial crops such as olive trees, asparagus, many types of fruit, and grazing crops for animal consumption. However, agricultural grains, which make up over 70 percent of global croplands, are almost always annual crops that need to be replanted every year.

Unlike perennials, annual crops require farmers to use soil-intensive practices such as tilling, plowing, and applying herbicides to reseed fields. The soil essentially has to be cleared of anything that might compete with the annual crops as they grow anew. Land management practices involved with annual grains are costly for the climate and farmers alike.

By requiring fewer soil-intensive practices, perennials make it easier to keep soil healthy, and healthy soil is important for more than just a good yield. It can also increase resilience to climate change impacts and provide carbon sequestration services. The term soil encompasses organic matter and living organisms that allow the soil to take in and store water when it rains. Soil health—as determined by its biological, chemical, and physical state—refers to the capacity of the soil to function as a living ecosystem that sustains plants, animals, and people. The healthier the soil, the greater its capacity to hold water, which makes croplands more resilient against both drought and flooding. Just a one percent increase in organic matter within the soil would allow U.S. croplands to store the amount of water that flows over Niagara Falls in 150 days. Farmers can minimize the need for tillage, which disrupts the soil structure that enables water storage, by transitioning to perennial grain systems in combination with other methods of regenerative agriculture.

Kernza perennial grain. Credit: The Land Institute.

When soil is undisturbed by industrial land management practices, it stores more than just water—it also stores carbon, making it an effective tool for climate change mitigation. Plants grow through the process of photosynthesis by absorbing sunlight and carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and water from the soil and converting them into energy and oxygen. Eventually, some of that carbon ends up in the soil via the plant’s roots as they die off or transfer carbon to the soil microbes. The longer lifespan of perennial grain crops allows for well-developed root systems to extend deep into the ground, which helps maintain a healthy level of organic matter necessary to trap and store carbon. Perennial crops also provide the soil with continuous coverage from above, protecting it from soil erosion (deterioration of the fertile top layer) and further supporting its capacity for carbon sequestration as well as climate resilience. Other benefits of perennial grain crops include reducing soil erosion, improving nutrient retention, and promoting biodiversity.

The Land Institute is a well-established leader in the field of perennial crop development. The non-profit research organization develops farming practices that mimic natural systems. This approach, referred to as Natural Systems Agriculture, combines a return to traditional farming techniques with scientific advancements in plant breeding in order to work with the environment rather than against it. The two main objectives of Natural Systems Agriculture are to provide ample food and eliminate the negative impacts of industrial agriculture. While its focus is on perennial grains, The Land Institute is also working to produce perennial legumes, rice, and oilseed crops.

Natural Systems Agriculture is guided by research in ecological intensification. Chief Communications Officer Tammy Kimbler spoke with EESI to explain what ecological intensification is, and how The Land Institute is using it to develop a grain agriculture based on perenniality and diversity. “Ecological intensification aims to harness ecological processes to maintain fertility, keep pests and pathogens in check, and prevent the loss of soil, nutrients, and organic matter,” she said. “Scientists are researching perennial grain crops, like perennial cereals and legumes, and how to grow these perennial grains… to achieve ecological intensification in agriculture.”

The Land Institute’s Kernza research technician, Marty Christians, heads into the field for harvesting with interns Crystal Ma and Konilo Zio. Credit: The Land Institute.

For researchers at The Land Institute, natural perennial ecosystems like prairies are the gold standard for Natural Systems Agriculture. “This system contrasts with chemical-based input intensification responsible for increased industrial agriculture yields last century,” Kimbler stated.

The cost of tillage and planting operations for annual systems, as well as the high volume of seeds needed for replanting, can be an economic burden for farmers. There is also a great deal of labor required to replant annual crops after every harvest. Given all the benefits of perennials and the disadvantages of annuals, why are annual varieties of grain considered standard crops in modern agriculture? The answer is rooted in short-term reliability bolstered by policy incentives. Because of their short lifespan, annual grains are adept at growing quickly and producing high yields. The predictable results associated with annuals are encouraged by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) through their eligibility requirements for federal crop insurance, leaving farmers responsible for the financial risk if they transition away from annuals and other industrial agricultural practices.

Despite these obstacles, perennial grains have made significant progress in the last two decades. In 2009, The Land Institute developed KernzaⓇ perennial grain, the first commercially available and economically viable perennial grain crop. It is a domesticated version of wild intermediate wheatgrass (Thinopyrum intermedium) and can be used as a substitute for annual wheat. Kernza’s sweet and nutty flavor profile gives a distinctive characteristic to the wide range of food and beverage products it can be used for. The versatility of the grain, which has a weaker gluten than wheat flour, makes it a suitable ingredient for bread, cereals, beer, whiskey, and even ice cream.

Trays of Kernza plants in a greenhouse. Credit: The Land Institute.

Kernza ripens in a new breeding plot. Credit: The Land Institute.

Currently, there are just under 4,000 acres of Kernza being grown across the United States, primarily in Minnesota. While Kernza seed is much smaller than annual wheat seed, plant breeders at The Land Institute have doubled its size since the grain was first registered, which has also resulted in higher yields. In 2020, the USDA provided $10 million to help scale up the cultivation of Kernza.

According to Kimbler, “The biggest obstacle for farmers [who want to transition to perennial polyculture] is having processing and markets available that are adequate and accessible in their regions. The USDA can help by providing funding to support infrastructural investments and early adoption… specifically for perennial grain processing.” She continued, “Farmers also need rural development programs, like a Rural Energy for America Program, that incentivize companies to adopt perennial grains into their products. Developing a Rural Perennial Grains Pilot Program modeled on the Rural Energy Pilot Program would greatly benefit farmers and de-risk adoption.” Such a pilot program would amplify the market demand for perennial products to help achieve scale.

Federal policy is starting to recognize the value of perennial crops and other methods of sustainable agriculture like cover cropping, crop diversification, agroforestry, soil amendments, and rotational grazing. For example, the USDA moved to invest billions of dollars in climate smart agriculture in 2022 through the Partnerships for Climate-Smart Commodities and the Inflation Reduction Act (P.L. 117-169).

Also in 2022, the USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service’s (NRCS’s) Conservation Stewardship Program (CSP) was updated to include perennials, which will help direct conservation funding towards the adoption of perennial grain crops like Kernza. The Land Institute believes this could be taken a step further, according to Kimbler, by “revising the NRCS rankings of practices” to increase the incentives for people using perennial practices in CSP. There is much potential for future progress, such as federal crop insurance reform, in the upcoming reauthorization of the Farm Bill.

Author: Alison Davis