Advanced Search
November 17, 2026
Louisiana’s coast has rapidly receded to a “point of no return” that climate mitigation cannot overcome. Since the 1930s, sea level rise, erosion, land subsidence, and other factors—all caused or accelerated by human activity—have claimed 2,000 square miles of its shore. According to some projections, 75% of its remaining wetlands will have disappeared by 2070, and eventually, the coastline will have moved over 30 miles inland from New Orleans.
Although the state is often considered the poster child for disappearing coastlines, Louisiana’s problem is not unique: sea levels along the Southeast and Gulf coasts have risen at unprecedented rates since 1900 via natural and human causes. For instance, 3.1 of the 9.4 inches of sea level rise along North Carolina’s coast since 1979 have been attributed to climate change.
The loss of coastal land impacts communities, particularly those with deep ties to the land. In Louisiana, more than one out of ten Native Americans (primarily members of the Chitimacha Tribe and the United Houma Nation) will be at risk of severe flooding in 2050 because they live in vulnerable coastlands. In the United States as a whole, almost 40% of Americans—129 million people—live in coastal counties. Not all are at risk of coastal flooding, but 2.5 million Americans are.
In this new era of extreme flooding and storm surges, many states are reconsidering their coastal plans to adapt to rising threats. Most state coastal plans focus on mitigating floods and coastal erosion through barriers, levees, and fortified coastlines. However, new research focused on Louisiana argues that states must go beyond mitigation and resilience and ultimately consider coastal retreat as preventing shore loss becomes physically impossible.
Coastal retreat, also known as managed retreat or managed relocation, focuses on relocating coastal communities and infrastructure inland. Relocating individuals and communities, especially marginalized populations or those with cultural ties to the land, is an extremely complex project that requires careful policy planning. Despite the need for careful planning, a study on a large sample of coastal communities found that only 8% of them had a coastal retreat plan in their local planning documents. Louisiana and other coastal states can lead by example to prevent loss of life and property through coastal relocation.
Governments can pursue a multitude of managed retreat policies, such as voluntary buyouts of private property, long-term community relocation, relocation of vulnerable or critical infrastructure, mandatory resettlements, restrictions on construction in high-risk areas, and setback zones near coastlines.
“Downzoning” and setback initiatives can be implemented decades before serious relocation concerns even arise. With “downzoning,” local governments decrease the density or intensity of development allowed near coasts. In setback zones, construction is completely prohibited over a certain distance from the water. Delaware, Maine, North Carolina, and many other states restrict construction near the coast, with rolling setbacks that intensify as the coastline recedes.
Once it becomes clear that residential areas are at severe risk of flooding, voluntary buyouts are a common relocation tool. Through buyout programs, local, state, or federal agencies purchase flood-vulnerable homes from residents to encourage relocation.
Long-term community relocation involves moving entire neighborhoods or communities, and requires long-term planning to ensure that local leaders and community members are able to drive the project and that adequate critical infrastructure is relocated or built on the relocation site.
When choosing a retreat policy, county, state, and federal governments consider several factors, including the degree and timing of retreat. Depending on flooding intensity, states may choose a partial retreat by moving only critical infrastructure, then gradually encouraging people to move inland. Another consideration is whether retreat needs to be individual or community-based. For instance, some Native American nations may prefer to relocate as a community rather than individually.
Cost is also an important criterion when considering a coastal retreat strategy: how much monetary compensation should be given to individuals who are relocating, and who should pay? How will municipalities handle a shrinking population and decreasing tax revenue after some residents take buyouts? Often, residents leave not only their homes but also their jobs and small businesses. Local governments may oppose relocation if it means fewer residents and less tax revenue to support their communities. In these cases, Kristin Uiterwyk, director of the Urban Harbors Institute at UMass Boston, suggests that state governments can step in to support municipalities facing financial burdens.
The National Wildlife Federation’s Kate Vogel and Zoë Kuntze urge decision-makers not to forget the land left behind and instead consider how to manage it—and even maximize its use—after relocation. They suggest asking: How can this land be leveraged to boost climate resilience, and what happens to the infrastructure—from homes and roads to sewer systems and transmission cables—that is left there? For instance, Uiterwyk notes that governments can increase the resilience of post-buyout land by restoring it as a floodplain.
Several states and municipalities are leading relocation projects that others can replicate. New Jersey’s Department of Environmental Protection has run its successful Blue Acres program since 1995. The plan offers coastal residents voluntary buyouts, allowing property owners in flood-prone areas to sell their land to the government before a disaster. The program then uses the bought-out land for floodplain restoration, which allows natural rivers to overflow their banks, minimizes erosion, and slows water flow to reduce downstream flooding. Ultimately, the buyouts address community needs, improve climate resilience, and support thoughtful land stewardship.
New York’s Blue Buffers program is another successful buyout program. Blue Buffers is funded by the state’s widely-supported Clean Water, Clean Air, and Green Jobs Environmental Bond Act of 2022 (S.B. 8008C). Unlike Blue Acres' application-based format, Blue Buffers requires the government to invite individuals to take buyouts.
Beyond state and local governments, other entities, like Buy-In Community Planning, help local communities design voluntary relocation programs. Buy-In planned a relocation and restoration program, Cherokee Forest Relocation to Restoration, in collaboration with local Mississippians. A resident study found that 84% of Cherokee Forest property owners were interested in a buyout.
Vogel also pointed to Maryland and Delaware, whose governments both recently created proactive coastal retreat plans and incorporated them into their state climate action plans. Maryland’s plan recommends collaborating with Agency Resilience Liaisons to share information about community-driven relocation. She added that Maryland had already conducted buyouts before its plan’s release and is currently working on a survey to gauge community perceptions of relocation. The University of Delaware is similarly researching potential retreat policies. Uiterwyk highlighted the Massachusetts Coastal Relocation Network and its collaborative work supported by state funding and The Nature Conservancy’s Massachusetts chapter. In Massachusetts, community workshops and practitioner trainings have been held to introduce relocation as a real option that can benefit people and nature together. Kuntze also emphasized that other states, like Maine, have looked to Massachusetts as an example for forming coastal relocation plans. And in Rhode Island, the town of Warren approved a plan, Market to Metacom, to relocate at-risk homes from flood-prone Market Street to Metacom Avenue.
At the federal level, the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA’s) Hazard Mitigation Grant Program (HMGP) has supported voluntary buyouts since its creation in 1988. These buyouts target flood-prone properties and often span years before buyout approval, compared to New Jersey’s Blue Acres program, which usually takes less than a year. From 1989 to 2017, FEMA funded 43,633 voluntary buyouts across 49 states and three U.S. territories. HMGP tends to focus on disaster relief following hurricanes and floods to reduce long-term damage to life and property. FEMA’s Community Rating System (CRS) is another useful federal tool that can reduce flood insurance premiums for communities that go beyond the National Flood Insurance Program’s minimum requirements for floodplain management, helping homeowners save money. The program, “when applied correctly, is an excellent example of interagency coordination,” Vogel noted.
Another resource in the federal relocation toolbelt is the Voluntary Community-Driven Relocation (CDR) Program, which supports tribal communities interested in relocating. As of 2022, CDR had prepared three communities for relocation: the Native villages of Napakiak and Newtok in Alaska, and the Quinault Indian Nation in Washington state. Also as of 2022, eight communities were working with CDR and the Bureau of Indian Affairs’ Branch of Tribal Community Resilience to plan for future relocation. Unlike more preventative or individual measures, these are entire community relocation efforts, which can be more challenging.
If residents feel voiceless in the relocation planning process, contempt and distrust will grow. For example, Vogel mentioned the relocation of the Isle de Jean Charles community in Louisiana. Residents could not apply for funding on their own and had to work with a state agency to plan for relocation. Tribe council members found this process confining, as their vision of relocation did not align with the agency’s vision.
Like the Isle de Jean Charles community, the Central Yup’ik people in Newtok, Alaska, also faced challenges during their relocation under the CDR program. Initial issues arose in choosing a location: the new area had to meet the community's needs, be close enough for relocation, and still be far enough inland to avoid the same risks of flooding and erosion. Eventually, the community relocated to Mertavik, but immediately faced infrastructure burdens such as issues with electricity, water, heat, and waste management infrastructure, as well as gaps in the ceilings of their new homes that let in cold air. KYUK, a public media source for the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta region of Alaska, hired a professional to inspect Mertavik homes after the Department of Urban and Housing Development failed to provide inspection reports. Several homes were reported to be in disrepair and built on unsalvageable foundations. Although the federal government provided funding to both the Jean Charles Choctaw Nation and the Newtok Village Council, requirements that limited the tribes’ self-determination and the lack of a centralized federal relocation agency caused new problems.
The Isle de Jean Charles and Newtok community resettlement projects demonstrate the need to streamline managed retreat’s funding processes. According to Kuntze, there are “currently a lot of different entry points for receiving funding support.” To speed up the process, state and federal governments can reorganize and centralize these processes. This can be done by reviewing application rules or by removing certain post-disaster declaration mandates—that is, specific legal requirements for governments and individuals seeking financial aid. Along with simplifying and strengthening existing federal programs like the CRS or CDR, many communities suggest creating a designated federal agency for relocation. A dedicated agency could work closely with local councils to consider each community’s unique concerns.
Although large-scale community relocation projects face systemic challenges, multiple municipalities and states have successfully implemented other types of relocation projects. Voluntary and individual-based buyout programs, like New Jersey’s Blue Acres, tend to be very successful for managed retreat. Blue Acres, which has bought over 1,200 properties since its inception, on average takes only six months to a year to close on projects, substantially shorter than the three to seven years that is typical for federal buyouts. Alongside speedy buyouts, Blue Acres helps low-income residents who cannot afford moving expenses or an attorney to review acquisition documents by collaborating with nonprofits to provide financial and legal assistance. Many buyout properties have been restored to floodplains, which can serve as a buffer during coastal storms while also providing bike trails and lush native forests for recreation and conservation. Other states can use New Jersey’s model to develop and implement their own coastal retreat plans.
Most importantly, authorities should note the importance of collaborating with community members. Kuntze emphasized the government's role in educating coastal residents about coastal erosion and why proactive retreat is advisable or even necessary. This sentiment was echoed by Uiterwyk, who explained that, during the retreat process, communities need opportunities to celebrate and commemorate the places they are leaving. Managed retreat practitioners can also reframe the narrative around the concept itself. Small things like saying “proactive coastal relocation” instead of “managed retreat”—which can sound like an act of forceful surrender—can change people’s thought processes. Coastal retreat can be devastating without advance action, but with proper planning, federal, state, and local governments can collaboratively pave the way for the future of coastal climate adaptation.
Author: Lauren Kim